Astrological symbols are not arbitrary—they emerge from a structured psycho-metaphysical system with clear functions, meanings, and domains of influence. Yet, many people project personal interpretations onto these symbols, mistaking their subjective experiences for objective truths.
Recently, someone said:"I’m buying this Moon necklace because I think I need it in this phase of life—it speaks to me."
I asked:"What does the Moon mean to you?"
She replied:"Transformation."
But here’s the problem: the Moon has nothing to do with transformation.
This response is not based on Jyotish—it is a projection. She is not engaging with the Moon as it is but rather with her own psychological narrative about change. And that’s fine—she may still find personal meaning in it. But that is not Jyotish. The distinction matters because Jyotish is not a system of subjective symbolism; it is a psycho-metaphysical framework with precise meanings and functions.
The Moon Is Not Transformational—It Holds Patterns
In Jyotish, the Moon represents Manas—the mind, memory, emotional continuity, and receptivity. It does not break things apart, dissolve attachments, or create transformation. If anything, the Moon is the least transformational Graha because its primary function is to preserve patterns—for better or worse.
Transformation occurs when something breaks down, creating space for something new to emerge. This does not happen through the Moon—it happens through other Grahas and through the domain of the 8th house, Scorpio, and the process of destruction and renewal.
If the Moon were truly transformational, it wouldn’t be responsible for habit formation, emotional security, and attachment to the past. It wouldn’t struggle to let go—it would dissolve effortlessly. But that’s not what happens.
The truth is, transformation happens to the Moon, not because of it.
And isn’t it interesting that the Moon’s weakest position is precisely in the domain of transformation—0° to 3°20’ Scorpio, where it is debilitated?
The Moon faces the forces of upheaval and radical change and struggles to maintain emotional stability. If the Moon were naturally transformational, why would it be debilitated at the exact point where transformation is strongest?
The suffering people experience in times of change is not caused by transformation itself—it is caused by the Moon’s inability to let go.
The Moon’s Role in Psychological Resistance
Transformation is rarely easy because the Moon’s primary function is to hold onto emotional security, memory, and familiarity.
People resist transformation because of the Moon.
People suffer through transformation because of the Moon.
People cling to old patterns even when they need to break because of the Moon.
The entire psychostructure often works through the Moon, attempting to release attachments, move on, and allow something new to enter. But the Moon does not create this process—it is simply the structure through which the process is either resisted or allowed.
This is why people experience prolonged suffering during major life shifts. It’s not the transformation itself that is painful—it’s the Moon’s struggle to let go.
A Meditative Moon: The True Key to Transformation
If the Moon becomes spacious, fluid, and adaptable, transformation can occur without suffering. A meditative Moon, one that writes on water, allows change to happen without extreme crisis.
Santosha (contentment, satiation) and Sukha (well-being, ease, flow, being in a good space internally) allow the Moon to let go gracefully.
A Moon that is spacious rather than clinging does not need external force to change.
The deeper one relaxes into reality, the less suffering transformation requires.
The problem is not transformation itself—the problem is our resistance to it. And resistance is the Moon’s specialty.
How Projection Distorts Jyotish
When someone sees the Moon as transformational, they are not seeing the Moon—they are seeing their own psychological association with change.
This kind of projection is common in Jyotish:
Someone might say, "Mars is about attraction because it’s passionate!" (Mistaking Mars for Venus.)
Someone else might claim, "Saturn is about creativity because discipline leads to mastery!" (Ignoring that Saturn restricts and delays, while Venus and Mercury play larger roles in creativity.)
Many people falsely reduce Rahu to ‘bad’ and Ketu to ‘spiritual’, failing to grasp their complex functions in the psyche.
These distortions emerge because people are importing the symbolic flexibility of New Age systems (like Tarot or Western archetypal astrology) into Jyotish—a discipline that does not operate on free-associative meaning but on an intricate psycho-metaphysical structure.
The Importance of Proper Symbolism in Jyotish
Jyotish is not a system of "whatever meaning resonates with me"—it is a precise psycho-metaphysical discipline grounded in:
Ontological Structure – The reality of planetary influences and their distinct functions.
Epistemological Coherence – Meaning is derived from Jyotish principles, not subjective interpretations.
Soteriological Purpose – Jyotish is designed to reveal the deeper psycho-structural forces at play, not to serve personal narratives.
If Jyotish were meant to be free-form, why would it place the Moon’s weakest point exactly where transformation is strongest (Scorpio 0°-3°20’)? This specificity shows that Jyotish operates within a structured psycho-metaphysical reality, not symbolic randomness. This is just one small example. The point is to see that there is a certain logic and methodology that Jyotish employees.
Seeing Symbols As They Are, Not As We Want Them to Be
Jyotish does not exist to confirm our personal narratives—it exists to reveal the psycho-metaphysical design of reality. The moment one begins projecting personal meaning onto planetary symbols, they cease to engage with Jyotish and instead engage with their own unconscious material.
Transformation is not an internal shift in mood—it is the destruction of an existing structure, making way for something new. That destruction is caused by other Grahas—not the Moon.
Thus, when someone says:"The Moon represents transformation,"they are not seeing the Moon—they are seeing their own narrative about change.
In reality, the Moon resists transformation—unless it is trained to let go gracefully.
To practice Jyotish correctly, one must discipline the mind to see symbols as they are, not as they wish them to be. The real work of a Jyotishi is not just reading charts—but removing the illusions that distort reality.
And it is for this reason that most Jyotishis, lacking confidence in their understanding of its foundations and philosophy, resort to Tarot, palmistry, numerology, and other tools to aid and confirm what is simply not clear to them in their Jyotish.
Comments